What are the advantages and disadvantages of VHF and MF/HF radio for maritime communication? (2024)

VHF stands for very high frequency, and it refers to the radio waves that range from 30 to 300 MHz. VHF radio is widely used for short-range communication between ships, coast stations, and aircraft. It is also the primary means of distress, urgency, and safety calls in the GMDSS. VHF radio has several advantages, such as high clarity, low interference, low power consumption, and easy installation. However, it also has some drawbacks, such as limited range, line-of-sight propagation, and vulnerability to weather conditions.

MF/HF stands for medium frequency and high frequency, and it refers to the radio waves that range from 300 kHz to 30 MHz. MF/HF radio is used for long-range communication between ships and coast stations, as well as for broadcasting maritime safety information (MSI) and navigational warnings. MF/HF radio has some advantages, such as long range, over-the-horizon propagation, and multiple frequency options. However, it also has some disadvantages, such as low clarity, high interference, high power consumption, and complex installation.

VHF radio is mainly used for routine and emergency communication within a local area. It can also be used for digital selective calling (DSC), which is a feature that allows you to send and receive pre-programmed messages with a unique identification number. DSC can be used to alert other stations of your distress, urgency, or safety situation, or to establish voice communication with a specific station. VHF radio can also be used for automatic identification system (AIS), which is a system that transmits and receives information about the identity, position, course, and speed of nearby vessels.

MF/HF radio is mainly used for long-distance and global communication, as well as for receiving MSI and navigational warnings. It can also be used for DSC, but with different frequencies and formats than VHF radio. MF/HF radio can also be used for radiotelex, which is a system that allows you to send and receive text messages over radio waves. Radiotelex can be used for exchanging operational and commercial information, such as weather reports, port clearance, cargo manifests, and invoices.

VHF radio has some challenges that may affect its performance and reliability. One of the main challenges is the limited range of VHF radio, which depends on the height of the antenna, the power output, and the curvature of the earth. VHF radio usually has a range of about 20 to 40 nautical miles, but it can be reduced by obstacles, such as mountains, buildings, or bridges. Another challenge is the line-of-sight propagation of VHF radio, which means that the radio waves travel in a straight line and cannot bend around the earth or reflect off the ionosphere. This limits the coverage of VHF radio and makes it susceptible to shadow zones and dead spots. A third challenge is the vulnerability of VHF radio to weather conditions, such as rain, fog, snow, or lightning. These conditions can cause attenuation, distortion, or interference of the radio signals.

MF/HF radio also has some challenges that may affect its performance and reliability. One of the main challenges is the low clarity of MF/HF radio, which is affected by the noise level, the signal strength, and the modulation mode. MF/HF radio often suffers from static, hissing, crackling, or fading of the audio quality, which makes it difficult to understand the messages. Another challenge is the high interference of MF/HF radio, which is caused by other radio sources, such as other stations, natural phenomena, or man-made devices. These sources can create unwanted signals that overlap or mask the desired signals. A third challenge is the high power consumption of MF/HF radio, which requires a large battery capacity and a good generator system. MF/HF radio also needs a complex installation, which involves a long antenna, a tuner unit, a grounding system, and a protection device.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

GMDSS

+ Follow

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.