Seven tips for finding the best pumpkins at the patch (2024)

Natasha Vaughn| Albany Bureau

ALBANY - Do you know how to pick the best pumpkin this fall?

With Halloween just weeks away, Stephen Reiners, a professor or horticulture at Cornell University and vegetable expert, said there are key things to look for when choosing the best pumpkin this year.

And this is a great year for it, Reiners said: Recent weather makes this an ideal year for pumpkins.

SLEEPY HOLLOW HALLOWEEN: The Blaze, Horseman's Hollow, cemetery tours

PUMPKINS: Where you can pick your own in the Hudson Valley​

“What started off as kind of a scary pumpkin season, in terms of what we might get, really turned around by mid-to-late August -- when we got a lot of warm dry temperatures day after day, and a lot of sun and heat and cooler nights," Reiners told the USA Today Network's Albany Bureau.

"And that really helped ripen the pumpkins up and turn them a beautiful shade of orange."

The dry weather, he added, also "helped in terms of keeping diseases down. They’re not soft. They’re looking excellent.”

So when you're out looking for the best pumpkin, here's seven tips to keep in mind, according to Reiners:

A hard sturdy stem

A soft or loose stem might be a clue that the pumpkin could be prone to rotting.

A green stem means the pumpkin has been freshly picked.

Tan or brown stems mean the pumpkin was harvested at least a few days ago.

Avoid the soft spots

Soft spots are a bad sign.

This could indicate that excess moisture or insects have gotten into the pumpkin and caused rot or mold.

And that means it shortens the time the pumpkin will look good sitting on your front porch.

Check for an uneven pumpkin

Before carving this year’s jack-o-lantern, try placing your pumpkin on a flat surface to see if it is going to roll.

Pumpkins with a flat bottom will be more likely to stand upright.

And that means they will stay in place when you put them on display.

Patience with the carving

Don’t rush to carve your pumpkin just yet.

A pumpkin will start to rot about a week after it’s carved.

So with Halloween still more than two weeks away, it might be a little early to clean it out.

Buying a pumpkin now and leaving it whole should last several weeks, and may still look all right through Thanksgiving -- that's if you can resist carving it.

Ripe is a matter of opinion

It’s OK to pick a pumpkin that’s not totally ripe.

Pumpkins continue to ripen and will get more orange after they are picked.

So choosing a lighter colored pumpkin now may result in a perfect deep orange pumpkin by Halloween.

Go small when baking

Pumpkins for carving are different from pumpkins for baking.

Larger pumpkins that are grown to be carving pumpkins are too stringy and can taste bitter. They have been grown for decoration and not eating.

Smaller pumpkins, sometimes called pie pumpkins, that weigh between four and six pounds are grown specifically for cooking and baking. So they have a better texture, and taste better as food.

Bumpy is fine

Like a bumpy pumpkin? Go for it.

When choosing a pumpkin to carve, people often overlook pumpkins and gourds with hardened bumps and bruises.

But beauty should be in the eye of the pumpkin picker.

The bumps do not affect the pumpkin and can add a unique spooky effect to your Halloween decor.

Seven tips for finding the best pumpkins at the patch (2024)

FAQs

Seven tips for finding the best pumpkins at the patch? ›

The skin should be firm and the stem should be attached. Avoid pumpkins with blemishes or bruises. We've covered sizing but next, you want to make sure that the pumpkin is nice and ripe. The best way to test this is to give the pumpkin a little thump – if it sounds hollow, it's ripe.

How do I find the best pumpkin? ›

The skin should be firm and the stem should be attached. Avoid pumpkins with blemishes or bruises. We've covered sizing but next, you want to make sure that the pumpkin is nice and ripe. The best way to test this is to give the pumpkin a little thump – if it sounds hollow, it's ripe.

How to pick a perfect pumpkin and make the best pie article? ›

Pick a winner at the pumpkin patch

Make sure it has no cracks, splits or soft spots that are a sign of rot. Gently press a fingernail into the rind. If you can easily push through the surface, the pumpkin was probably picked too early and will rot. A mature pumpkin will not easily scratch.

How often should I water pumpkins? ›

Pumpkins need 1 inch of water per week. Water deeply, in the morning and on very hot afternoons, especially during fruit set. Avoid watering foliage and fruit unless it's a sunny day.

How to pick a pumpkin from a pumpkin patch? ›

Avoid any pumpkins that have cracks or splits. Gently squeeze or press your fingers into the fruit. Pay close attention to the blossom end, or bottom, and around the stem. A fresh pumpkin should be solid to the touch.

What are three tips for choosing an ideal pumpkin? ›

So when you're out looking for the best pumpkin, here's seven tips to keep in mind, according to Reiners:
  • A hard sturdy stem. A soft or loose stem might be a clue that the pumpkin could be prone to rotting. ...
  • Patience with the carving. ...
  • Ripe is a matter of opinion. ...
  • Go small when baking. ...
  • Bumpy is fine.
Oct 13, 2017

What are the sweetest pumpkins? ›

Small Sugar

Possibly our sweetest pumpkin, Small Sugar is just the right size for roasting in the oven. The vigorous vines are heavy producers, forming many under-10-pound fruits that are ripe for picking 95 days from transplant. Small Sugar's smooth texture and rich flavor make it a perfect variety for pies and soups.

What does a sugar pumpkin look like? ›

Sugar pumpkins

These much smaller pumpkins are less stringy and sweeter. Their skin is softer, which makes it easier to cut as well. Look for round pumpkins that have a dark orange color, are about 10 inches (25 cm) and weigh no more than 10 pounds.

Are coffee grounds good for pumpkins? ›

Coffee grounds can either be sprinkled directly around the plants or diluted with water and added as a liquid feed. As well as being able to give pumpkins a nitrogen boost, coffee grounds also keep bugs away and can be used as a control method for slugs and snails.

What not to grow near pumpkins? ›

For example, pumpkins don't typically make good companions for potatoes, or anything in the brassicas (cabbage) family like cauliflower, kohlrabi, Brussels sprouts, or kale.

What's the best fertilizer for pumpkins? ›

Apply a weekly nitrogen-heavy fertilizer early in the growing season to produce a healthy plant. Once the flowers start to form, switch to a phosphorus-heavy fertilizer for plentiful blossoms. When the actual pumpkins appear, use a potassium-rich fertilizer for healthy fruit.

How to pick a good pumpkin at the store? ›

When selecting the perfect pumpkin, choose one with no soft spots. It should also be uniform in color, with no signs of mold or unusual discoloration. Also, pick a pumpkin that has its “handle,” or stem, intact.

Where can I find the great pumpkin? ›

Watch It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown - Apple TV+

How to buy the best pumpkin? ›

Shopping and storing for pumpkins

Look for pumpkins with firm and smooth orange skin and that feel heavy for their size. Avoid pumpkins with cracks and bruises. Whole pumpkins can be kept in a cool, dry place for several months.

How to pick the best pumpkin for cooking? ›

For cooking, you'll want to use sugar pumpkins (also called pie or sweet pumpkins), which are small and round. Long Island Cheese pumpkins, which are more oblong and can look like a wheel of cheese, are also good to eat. Field pumpkin types are larger, have watery, stringy flesh, and are best for decorating.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6072

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.